| James Blackmon Sr. | Marion | 1983 | |||||
| Richard Butt | Huntington | 1954 | |||||
| Henry Chapman * | Ft. Wayne Northside | 1955 | |||||
| John DeVoe * | Park School | 1952 | |||||
| Henry Ebershoff * | Lafayette Central Catholic | 1963 | |||||
| Brian Evans | Terre Haute South | 1991 | |||||
| Oscar Evans | Shortridge | 1968 | |||||
| Darrin Fitzgerald | Indianapolis Washington | 1983 | |||||
| Dennis Goins | Rushville | 1979 | |||||
| Ken Gunning * | Shelbyville | 1933 | |||||
| Jack Hogan | Broad Ripple | 1963 | |||||
| Kirk Manns | North Judson | 1986 | |||||
| Eric Montross | Lawrence North | 1990 | |||||
| Drake Morris | East Chicago Washington | 1977 | |||||
| Jim Oler * | Economy | 1952 | |||||
| Phil Snodgress * | Kennard | 1954 | |||||
| Brad Stevens | Zionsville | 1995 | |||||
| Mike Lightfoot (Silver Medal) | LaVille | 1974 |
